top of page

MCAS: Are We Treating the Symptoms but Missing the Cause?

3 days ago
9 min read

What is the root cause of MCAS, and why do some people develop Mast Cell Activation Syndrome in the first place?

Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS) is becoming increasingly recognised, particularly among people experiencing chronic, unexplained symptoms affecting multiple systems in the body.

But while much of the conversation around MCAS focuses on histamine, antihistamines, mast cell stabilisers and avoiding triggers, we believe there is another important question that deserves more attention.

Why have your mast cells become so reactive in the first place?


Woman experiencing multiple MCAS symptoms, including fatigue, brain fog, skin flushing, digestive problems and palpitations, illustrating how mast cell activation can affect different body systems.

MCAS is a recognised medical syndrome, but receiving a diagnosis doesn't necessarily explain why someone has developed it.

d it.

For some people, genetic predisposition may play a role. For others, underlying allergic or inflammatory conditions, infections, environmental exposures and other physiological factors may be contributing to their symptoms.

And sometimes, despite thorough investigation, the underlying cause remains unknown.


At The Autoimmune Clinic, we work with many people with suspected MCAS, and our approach goes beyond managing histamine-related symptoms.

We want to understand the bigger picture, identify possible contributing factors and understand whether there are areas of someone's health that can be addressed.

Because MCAS may explain what is happening in your body, but it doesn't explain why it is happening.


What Is Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS)?

Mast cells are immune cells found throughout the body, particularly in the skin, lungs, digestive tract and areas exposed to the outside environment.

They play an important role in protecting us against infections, responding to injury and coordinating inflammatory responses.

When activated, mast cells release substances such as histamine, prostaglandins, leukotrienes and cytokines.

These substances are essential for normal immune function. However, when mast cells become excessively or inappropriately activated, they can contribute to a wide range of symptoms, including:

  • Flushing, itching, hives and skin inflammation

  • Digestive symptoms such as bloating, abdominal pain and diarrhoea

  • Palpitations, dizziness and changes in blood pressure

  • Headaches, migraines and brain fog

  • Nasal congestion and respiratory symptoms

  • Severe allergic-type reactions, including anaphylaxis

Because mast cells are distributed throughout the body, symptoms can involve several organ systems and fluctuate considerably.


Why Understanding the Root Cause of MCAS Matters

Now, don't get us wrong. We work with many people with suspected MCAS. And we say suspected because getting a confirmed diagnosis can be challenging. Laboratory markers can be difficult to capture, particularly when samples need to be collected during or shortly after a flare.

Many people also experience symptoms suggestive of mast cell involvement without necessarily meeting the established diagnostic criteria for MCAS.

We understand how frustrating this can be, especially when someone has spent years struggling with unexplained symptoms, seeing different specialists and trying numerous treatments without finding long lasting relief.

Receiving a diagnosis can provide reassurance and validation. Finally, there is a possible explanation for what has been happening.

But we don't believe the investigation should necessarily stop there.


The next question should be: What is the underlying cause of this mast cell activation?

There may be a genetic predisposition, an underlying medical condition or other factors contributing to someone's symptoms.

Often several factors are involved simultaneously.

And while we cannot always identify or change the underlying cause of MCAS, there may be opportunities to address contributing factors and control symptoms better.

It is also important to distinguish between a root cause, a trigger that aggravates symptoms and a condition that happens to coexist with MCAS. These are not necessarily the same thing.


What Are the Possible Root Causes of MCAS?

There is no single root cause of MCAS that applies to everyone.

From a medical perspective, mast cell activation disorders may be classified as primary, secondary or idiopathic.

Primary mast cell disorders involve abnormalities within the mast cells themselves. Secondary mast cell activation occurs in response to another identifiable process, such as an allergic reaction. Idiopathic MCAS refers to cases where the diagnostic criteria are met but no underlying cause can be identified.

Beyond these classifications, there are several factors that may influence mast cell activity or contribute to symptoms.

At our clinic, we consider the following areas when reviewing someone's health history.


1. Can MCAS Have a Genetic Root Cause?

Some people have an inherited tendency towards altered mast cell activity.

For example, hereditary alpha-tryptasaemia is a genetic trait associated with elevated baseline tryptase levels and, in some individuals, increased mast cell-related symptoms.

Other genetic and biological factors may also influence how mast cells respond to different stimuli.

This is why we believe it is important to explore family history when investigating suspected MCAS. We often ask whether other family members experience similar patterns of symptoms, such as allergies, eczema, asthma, flushing, digestive problems, food sensitivities or unexplained reactions to medications and environmental triggers.

Looking at the family history can reveal patterns of immune reactivity or mast cell-related symptoms that may suggest an inherited predisposition, although these symptoms are common and do not necessarily indicate MCAS.

We cannot change someone's genetics, and having a genetic predisposition does not automatically mean they will develop MCAS.

However, understanding whether there may be an inherited component can help inform further medical investigation and symptom management.

And importantly, having a genetic predisposition doesn't mean that other contributing factors cannot be identified and addressed.


2. Can Gut Health and SIBO Contribute to MCAS?

The gastrointestinal tract contains large numbers of mast cells, which interact closely with the gut lining, immune system and nervous system.

In our clinic, we often see digestive symptoms alongside suspected mast cell activation.

These may include bloating, abdominal pain, diarrhoea, constipation, reflux and food sensitivities.

Conditions such as Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth (SIBO), Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) and other gastrointestinal disorders may coexist with mast cell-related symptoms.

There is also growing research into the relationship between the gut microbiome, intestinal inflammation and mast cell activity.

For some people, improving digestive health may help reduce their overall symptom burden, even if it doesn't directly treat the underlying mast cell disorder.


3. Can Chronic Infections Trigger Mast Cell Activation?

Mast cells are part of our immune defence system and respond to infections.

Viral, bacterial and fungal infections can activate mast cells and contribute to inflammatory responses.

Some people report the onset or worsening of mast cell-related symptoms following an infection, such as COVID-19.

Mast cell involvement has also been investigated in long COVID and other post-viral conditions.

In our clinic, we often see people whose health deteriorated following an infection and who subsequently developed a combination of digestive symptoms, food sensitivities, fatigue, flushing or other inflammatory symptoms.

This doesn't necessarily mean that an infection has caused MCAS.

However, understanding when symptoms began and whether there is evidence of an ongoing infection or inflammatory condition can be an important part of the investigation.


4. Can Mould Exposure and Environmental Factors Trigger MCAS?

Environmental exposures can be particularly challenging for people experiencing mast cell-related symptoms.

Commonly reported triggers include:

  • Pollen and dust mites

  • Mould and damp environments

  • Strong fragrances and cleaning products

  • Smoke and air pollution

  • Changes in temperature

  • Certain medications and food additives

At our clinic, we also work with people experiencing mould-related illness and suspected Chronic Inflammatory Response Syndrome (CIRS).

Some people report significant changes in their health following exposure to water-damaged buildings, including increased sensitivities and symptoms that overlap with suspected MCAS.

Our approach is to understand whether environmental factors are relevant to the individual, and whether reducing specific exposures may help improve symptoms.


5. Can Hormonal Changes Contribute to MCAS Symptoms?

Some women notice that their mast cell-related symptoms fluctuate with their menstrual cycle, during perimenopause or at other times of hormonal change.

Oestrogen and progesterone interact with immune signalling, and there is growing interest in how sex hormones influence mast cell activity.

For example, some women report increased itching, flushing, headaches or digestive symptoms at particular stages of their menstrual cycle.

Others notice changes in their symptoms during perimenopause, when hormone levels can fluctuate considerably.

Where appropriate, reviewing hormonal symptoms and considering the wider clinical picture may help identify additional factors contributing to someone's symptom burden.


6. Can Stress and Nervous System Dysregulation Affect MCAS?

One area we place considerable emphasis on at The Autoimmune Clinic is the relationship between mast cells and the nervous system.

Mast cells communicate with nerve cells and can respond to stress-related signalling.

For some people, periods of emotional or physical stress coincide with an increase in itching, flushing, digestive symptoms or other reactions.

Let's be clear, this doesn't mean that MCAS is in your head or that symptoms are "just" caused by stress.

It means that the immune system and nervous system are closely connected, and both may influence symptom severity.

We commonly work with people who have been experiencing chronic symptoms for years, often alongside considerable stress, disrupted sleep and an increasingly heightened response to everyday triggers.

In these situations, we may consider strategies such as improving sleep, pacing, relaxation, nervous system regulation and reducing unnecessary physiological stressors.

Although nervous system regulation is not an established cure for MCAS, we see it helps many people manage symptom triggers and improve their quality of life.


Are POTS, EDS and Autoimmune Conditions Linked to MCAS?

Another important part of investigating the possible root cause of MCAS symptoms is understanding whether other conditions are present.

In our clinic, we frequently work with people who experience symptoms associated with:

Some of these conditions share overlapping symptoms with MCAS.

For example, someone experiencing palpitations, dizziness and flushing may have several potential explanations for those symptoms.

Similarly, someone with digestive symptoms, food sensitivities and fatigue may have more than one condition contributing to how they feel.

We want to avoid assuming that every symptom is caused by MCAS simply because mast cells may be involved.

Sometimes investigating and managing a coexisting condition can make a meaningful difference to someone's overall health.


Are We Too Focused on Treating MCAS Symptoms Rather Than Investigating the Root Cause?use?se?e??

For someone experiencing significant mast cell-related symptoms, symptom relief is understandably the immediate priority.

Supplements, antihistamines, mast cell stabilisers and other medications can be really helpful in reducing symptoms.

Nutritional strategies and identifying individual triggers can also help.

But we are cautious about focusing exclusively on avoiding histamine or progressively restricting someone's diet.

We often see people who have removed so many foods that their diet has become extremely limited, leaving them worried about eating and potentially compromising their nutritional status.

A low-histamine diet may be useful for some individuals, but it is not a treatment for every cause of mast cell-related symptoms, and unnecessary long-term restrictions can create additional problems.


We don't want people to feel that their only option is to spend the rest of their lives avoiding foods, supplements and environmental exposures without ever exploring why they have become so reactive.


At the same time, it is important to be realistic.

Not every person with MCAS will have an identifiable or reversible root cause.

For some, ongoing medication and trigger management will remain essential.

Our aim is to support symptom management while also exploring whether there are other areas of health that need attention.

This might include digestive function, nutritional status, sleep, environmental exposures, coexisting conditions and nervous system regulation.

Not everyone will need the same investigations or interventions.


Can MCAS Be Reversed by Addressing the Root Cause??ten asked.

And the answer is that it depends.

If mast cell activation is occurring in response to an identifiable underlying condition, addressing that condition may help reduce symptoms.

For example, identifying an allergy, reviewing a medication that is triggering reactions or addressing an underlying inflammatory condition may help reduce mast cell activation.

However, this is not the same as saying that MCAS can always be cured or reversed.

Some people have primary mast cell disorders, while others have idiopathic MCAS, where no underlying cause can be identified.

For these individuals, long-term symptom management may be needed.

We believe it is important to offer realistic expectations rather than promise that identifying a root cause will automatically lead to recovery.

Nevertheless, where there are potentially modifiable contributing factors, we believe they are worth exploring.


Our Approach to Investigating Possible MCAS Root Causes

At The Autoimmune Clinic, we don't believe there is one single explanation for every person experiencing suspected MCAS.

Our role as nutritional therapists and functional medicine practitioners is not to diagnose MCAS, but to help clients understand their symptoms and investigate potentially modifiable factors.

We take the time to look at someone's health history, the onset of their symptoms, potential triggers, nutrition, digestive health, lifestyle and any relevant medical investigations.

Depending on the individual, our approach may include:

  • Reviewing their nutritional intake and identifying potential deficiencies

  • Investigating digestive symptoms and considering whether further testing is appropriate

  • Exploring possible environmental triggers and exposure history

  • Supporting gut health and nutritional diversity where tolerated

  • Considering the relationship between hormonal changes and symptom patterns

  • Incorporating nervous system regulation and stress management strategies

  • Working alongside medical professionals when further investigations or medication are required

Our goal is not to help someone avoid everything that makes them react.

It is to understand whether there are areas we can support to help improve their tolerance, reduce their symptom burden and improve their quality of life.

Because MCAS may explain what is happening, but it doesn't always explain why.

And while identifying the underlying cause is not always possible, we believe it is worth asking the question.



 
 
bottom of page